Skip navigation.
Home

what is with the 8 car train shit???

bartside's picture

who gives? why is bart running 8 car trains during rush hour? The damn platform was made to handle 10 cars. I didn't pay to ride bart only to get packed like fucking sardines in an 8 car train. aaaaarrrggggghhhhhh!!!!!!!

Train Operator since 2003's picture

There is only a certain # of

There is only a certain # of train cars available at any specific time due to maintenence and breakdowns e.t.c. and bart only has so many cars in the fleet. When the trains become crowded (we call it crush load) T/O's report it to central control... Somtimes we see "survey takers" These are the people in the vests with clipboards that pop their heads in the the train and guesstemate loads in the trains and then Management decides from the guesstimation numbers which train gets to have that precious 9th or 10th car.

Here is what I can suggest: Complain! simple, yet effective when done right. Ask an agent for a customer service card (or a stack of them) and fill it/them out (DO NOT CHEW UP THE AGENT THEY ARE ABUSED ENOUGH). This is the single most effective thing you can do. Operations managers are required to read them. The more people from a single train asking for more cars the better the odds of them getting one. Feel free to pass them about to each other.

Next: All you need to say on it is:

I Ride the ____o'clock train from _______ station to ______station every day and it is too crowded, This train usually has ______ # of cars and this is unacceptable it needs ______ # of cars. Please contact me concerning this matter.
They hate having to talk to people so the more folks that fill out a card the better your odds.

That is a good suggestion. I

That is a good suggestion. I guess I feel the same way that during rush hour it will be crowded. That means, every rider is paying and that equates to more money for BART. Don't you think riders should get a full 10 car train during rush hour?

I understand there are cars that are in maint or is down. I still think BART needs to provide that service buy getting more cars. Just because cars are in service doesn't mean people that would have been on those two extra cars stop taking bart.

The capacity of BART riders is full during the commute and BART needs to make sure they operate at full capacity. Where is the money going to avoid making the riders suffer? Fix the cars or buy more and give us service that we pay for.
Happy Riding!
BART nubee

Train Operator since 2003's picture

Unfortunately BART does not

Unfortunately BART does not care all that much about what the T/O's & S/A's think, they don't answer to us, they answer to the public.

In answering your question to me, of course I think my passengers should get 10 cars. If I had my way I'd program the operating software on the trains and on the rails to operate a 12 car train and just lock out the side doors on the end units, or more likely have two cars in the back locked out.

We can't put more trains on the rails (because we can't turn them around fast enough at the ends) but maybe we can make 'em longer. Oh well, someday if I get into management.....

As far as getting the service you pay for? Well I have two suggestions: The first one is my above response, the second is to start looking into where your money goes. BART is a public entity and their records are public information oh, and try not to notice the horrible math they have. The Union had independent auditors (Non ATU folks)go over the numbers and found quite a few interesting results. You would have to ask the ATU 1555 in Oakland about it because I forgot most of the details.

eastbayman's picture

it's not really that hard to

it's not really that hard to keep 10 trains. I like your idea of having 12 cars during commute. It's all math..if the system has more cars during commute that means more revenue because more riders are likely to take BART if you can actually sit down once in awhile.

all I know is that BART

all I know is that BART needs to purchase new trains. How old are the original Trains? It's been in service since 1972? It's time for management to stop giving themselves pay raises and spend it back on the system! Stop finding creative ways to generate money by making everyone pay for parking!!!!

It's time for BART to stop

It's time for BART to stop expensive extensions that offer less in return than doing needed expansion for the core of the system. The core of the system is crowded and needs upgrades and renovations.

If BART collected money from

If BART collected money from all the fare jumpers each day, they could buy some more cars. Many of the cars they run each day have mechanical issues. Coupled with the ones that are already down, it is TOO MANY. It is also annoying that the Pittsburg/Bay Point line doesn't go out to the airport any more and you have to transfer.

Congratulations! Now you get

Congratulations! Now you get to experience what other passengers had to experience when the Bay Point line went to the airport!

Deal with it. Just like everyone else had to do before the switch.

Read some of the other

Read some of the other posts. BART MANAGEMENTS HAS STATED THAT FARE EVASION IS NOT A PRIORITY.

Running less than 10 car

Running less than 10 car trains before 9:00 a.m. is totally unacceptable, regardless of the excuses. This is especially true for the Pittsburgh/Bay Point to SF/Daily City/Colma trains.
BART doesn't need some fucking survey to tell them this is bad.
I ride from the Orinda station. By the time an 8 car train gets to Orinda, it is packed. It gets even more packed at Rockridge.
The problem is exacerbated when trains are late, and becomes a total cluster fuck if a train goes out of service.
I'm sorry, but this is just piss poor planning, and bad customer service all around. If I had another viable alternative to driving, I'd take it. But, just like everyone else, I have to put up with the crappy service provided by BART, or get in my car and deal with the nightmare of the Bay Bridge Toll Plaze and parking in San Francisco.

the really insane thing is

the really insane thing is that I was going into San Francisco on a 6 car train one morning and when I got to Montgomery there was a 10 car train leaving for Concord. It was, of course, completely empty. 10 cars to Concord at 7:30 am on a weekday? Seriously?

dude, how do you think they

dude, how do you think they get the trains back to the other side of the bay so that they can have big trains coming into the city? dumb ass

hah, i can't believe i

hah, i can't believe i didn't think of that.

The empty train is a

The empty train is a "commuter special" it was turning around at Montgomery going to Concord that's why it was empty.

Speaking of small cars. We

Speaking of small cars. We had a five-car DIRTY train, standing room only, at 10:58 p.m. out of Embarcadero and do you think any of these morons would move their luggage or backpacks so they only occupy one seat? Then you get the drunk who gets on at Macarthur and asks if the train is going to Pittsburg 10 plus times and just stands in the door and won't get on and won't get off. Then, of course, he has to sing and whistle the entire train ride home. I had just gotten off a 10-hour shift and asked someone if I could sit where she had her backpack and she just sneered and made some rude noises but finally moved it. I thought gheese, did you buy two tickets? Doesn't BART have enough cars for the system? BART just keeps raising fares, etc., but the system and service just keeps degrading day-by-day. I've never understood the 8 car trains during the height of the commute hour going to and from SF to Pittsburg, nothing like feeling like a piece of abused cattle. BART rather just let people vandalize the train cars so they don't have any in service because BART Police won't get off their asses and do their jobs. Half the train cars in use are already broken in one way or another. Wonder if BART's mechanics are any better than their Police Department? Often, it takes about 10 tries to get out of the station when i'm going home. I just counting stations and hope for the best. I hate it when they single track at night too. They have no respect for the evening commuter. The think everyone who is on BART is drunk so they can get away with taking 1.5 to get people home and leaving the train doors open in freezing whether while they wait at Orinda for another train to pass. You would think they would do the maintenance after midnight, especially stuff like yellow squares. To close down one side of the station because of that and single track is so lame and what horrible management.

hey electric_eye you should

hey electric_eye you should check out the thread about gas caps, apparently people think I'm the only one who think BART police suck.

Now there are permanent

Now there are permanent signs telling passengers how to board 8 or 9 car trains during rush hour. So I'm guessing that shitty service is now the status quo. Unlike drinking Dr Pepper, 10, 2, and 4 is not the time to run 10 car trains. I want to congratulate the idiot(s) in Bart management who came up with this idea, and still get to keep their jobs.

I love trains, but BART

I love trains, but BART really could be so much better, so I don't ride much anymore. There are two fundamental problems with the system:

1. Not enough trains. Shorter trains might be OK if you ran more of them. Three per hour is not enough. Miss your train and wait 20 minutes! -just miserable. By way of comparison, the Yamanote line that loops around Tokyo runs trains 3 minutes apart (2 minutes at rush hour) or 20 per hour (up to 24/hr at rush hour)!

2. Far too frequent failure to keep to the published schedule. Again in contrast, Tokyo's trains are driven by human operators with some computer assistance for safety functions. They rarely fail keep to their schedule over thousands of runs per day. BART's failure to keep to the schedule has always been a major irritation to me, and it can be very very noisy in certain underground places.

I could go on and on for I am spoiled by what a truly great public transit train system can and should be. BART is a big disappointment. If you are interested, the coolest trains in Japan are the shinkansen (bullet trains, not 1 minute apart, but you don't have to wait 20 minutes either!). Check 'em out:

http://www.h2.dion.ne.jp/~dajf/byunbyun/gallery.htm

http://www.h2.dion.ne.jp/~dajf/byunbyun/pics/500f.htm

Cheers...

So, when are you moving to

So, when are you moving to Japan? I hear you can get an apartment in Tokyo much cheaper than one in downtown SF? Har har harrrrrr deeee har har.

Japan has to run trains more

Japan has to run trains more frequently because of their situation. Hardly anyone in Tokyo owns a automobile. Almost everyone there uses public transportation to get around. The greater Tokyo metro area has over 33 MILLION residents. The bay area has about 7 million. See what I'm getting at?

That's why Tokyo runs trains more frequently. They have to move wayyyyyy more people than we do here in the bay area. If the bay area had 33 million residents, I'm pretty sure BART would run differently.

So you continuing to compare Tokyo transit to BART is rediculous. They are in a totally different situation than we are here. Lastly, trains are 20 minutes apart ONLY on weekends and after 7PM when ridership is at it's lowest. A little over 300,000 riders a day use BART during the week. Not even 300,000 riders use BART on Saturday and Sunday COMBINED. Running trains on a weekday schedule on weekends would be complete overkill, and a waste of money for BART. Haven't you ever heard of supply and demand?

But you don't think about those things because you're too busy rubbing one out to Tokyo's subway system.

I've heard that by running

I've heard that by running shorter trains, BART saves money on electricity. Appearently they save a lot of money just by taking one or two cars off the trains (this is why you have the shorter Dublin/Pleasanton trains going to SFO and Milbrae). Though, I don't see why they just cut one or two cars off trains in the middle of the day when no one rides, so instead of cutting 10 car trains to 8 cars, they cut 6 car trains to 4 cars.

Furthermore, I agree with almost everything everyone has said. Bart needs to run more trains more frequently to handle the loads of passengers. If there are not enough cars in the fleet, then they should just buy more.

Also, when are the yellow platform tiles going to be replaced at Orinda station? Most of them have fallen off and you can even see the nice mosaics from the 70's. It is extremely hazardous to not have the yellow tiles, especially when it is raining and the platform is slippery.

Loads of passengers? You

Loads of passengers? You must only ride the trains during commute because that's the only time trains are packed other than when events are going on. If EVERY train regardless of what time of the day or where it was going was jam packed, you'd have a good argument. But that's not the case. I operate 6 car trains sometimes that would actually be sufficient being 3 car trains because of the light passenger load. Like I said, commute, and events are the only times BART is really moving tons of people. Other than that, it's relativley light.

And FYI, the yellow tiles are not to keep you from slipping on the platform. They're there to represent a safety barrier between you and the train, only to be breached when entering or exiting a train. Other than that, you really shouldn't be on the yellow tiles to begin with.

Operator9, Are you married?

Operator9, Are you married? I just love you! Your responses to the ignorant BART riders are always spot on and truly educational. Seriously, you inform the general public better than BART's spokesperson whats-his-face, Litton Johnson? You tell it like it is without all that public relations crap getting in the way. Keep up the good work. BART needs more employees willing to speak up the way you do.

hmmm, do we have a match

hmmm, do we have a match between BARTAVENGER and Operator9? Another BART success story...

I'm single if you're cute

I'm single if you're cute and a female.

Well, one out of two ain't

Well, one out of two ain't bad....I'm female anyway and probably old enough to be your mother! You just keep up your good work here. I never realized there were so many ignorant BART riders. The comments here are funnier than the comic page.

Right, that is why the tiles

Right, that is why the tiles are made from non-stick rubber and have traction grips built into them. They are there so that you don't slip when you enter and exit the train IN ADDITION to being a safety barrier.

As a train operator I can't blame you for seeing it that way though. It must be really stressful to enter a platform when there are passengers encroaching on the yellow line. Seriously, what kind of nightmares do you have?

ADA-The yellow "safety

ADA-The yellow "safety strip" serves the disbled more than any other purpose it might have. The bumpy surface informs the blind to STOP or else they'd end up walking off the platform. Addtionally, there is a difference in texture between the yellow tiles and the black ones. This serves to inform the blind and other vision impaired passengers where to board the train. Otherwise, they'd be walking into the sides of the train. Thanks to an ADA lawsuit against BART the disbled can now use the trains more easily. Platform announcements to identify which train is approaching...for those who can't see the flashing overhead sign; elevators (which fare evaders use to sneak on the trains) were installed after BART lost the lawsuit...that's why so many of them are on the outside of the faregates....were not installed for strollers, bicycles and shopping carts. The elevators were installed for wheelchair users and other disbled who cannot use stairs or escalators. I'm surprised the train operators don't know this about the yellow tiles.

We do know this. I said it

We do know this. I said it was a safety barrier. Just because I didn't go into eloquent detail like you did, doesn't mean we as train operators don't know about the yellow tiles. Stop making assumptions. It's one of the thousand things that's drilled into our heads during training, so we're very aware of that and ADA issues.

Hey, I'm on YOUR side

Hey, I'm on YOUR side beleive it or not! You know as well as I do that the average BART rider is ignorant of why BART works the way it does. Sometimes we have to break it down to the simplest form so they can understand it. That's all I was trying to do. I didn't mean to besmearch your skill and knowledge as a train operator.

BART cars are over a million

BART cars are over a million dollars each, and BART would be happy to purchase more if y'all wouldn't mind fares rising again to cover the cost of purchasing more. And they can't run more trains because there wouldn't be enough trackway to accomodate them all (especially in the Y in Oakland). The yellow tiles are being replaced, but it will take them awhile to get to Orinda. Two Berkeley stations have already had theirs replaced and there's a schedule for replacement at other stations.

you're kidding! 1 million

you're kidding! 1 million per car? that sounds outrageous. So an 8 car train is $8 million?

That's exactly why BART

That's exactly why BART Police should ride the trains and kick the stinky homeless off and other people who are vandalizing and trashing the cars, as well as drunk people puking and peeing all over the place. It is useless to have BART Police in their cars because people on the train don't want to wait for them to get out of their car and up to the train when something is going on.

So, should they be on the

So, should they be on the trains to cite people with food and beverages or should they be in the stations citing fare evaders?

To get this thread "back on

To get this thread "back on track" so to speak, I still contend that Bart is oblivious to providing good customer service by running shortened trains during peak commute hours. Why is this acceptable? Why are there half-full 10 car trains in the middle of the day, and 8 car trains in the morning that are so packed that people are left standing on the platform waiting for the next train? Between 6:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m, and between 4:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m., all trains should be 10 cars. Period. I don't want to hear any more lame excuses about having to clean cars, or do maintenance. This should be done between midnight and 6:00 a.m., or during the middle of the day. Bart administration will argue that their hands are tied because of union contracts, etc., but this is bullshit. The transit system exists for commuters, not the livelihood of Bart employees.

You're totally correct here,

You're totally correct here, but here lies the problem.

Commuters in the bay area are too lazy, or unmotivated to do or say anything about the conditions of cars, and the quality of service. So in management's eyes, everything is gravy since none of the passengers seem to mind the current state of affairs. Nobody is making a big issue out of these problems, so what's the big deal?

You can't hear people that aren't saying or doing anything.................

and that's why we should all

and that's why we should all fare evade on Monday, July 10th. Get bart management to stop the fare evaders and increase the cash flow so they CAN buy new train cars; improve the station facilities; replace 30+yr old tracks; hire more police officers; and earthquake the transbay tube and Berkeley hills tunnel.

Yeah, especially after a

Yeah, especially after a Giants game; I couldn't believe they did that. How cruel. I hate riding home with a bunch of drunks as it is.

The yellow edge detection

The yellow edge detection tiles are for ADA compliance. Period. Shame on a TO for not knowing this. BART station platforms only accommodate 10-car trains. A train with more than 10 cars won't fit at the platform, although they've been sent out that way from the yard. BART puts longer trains out during the day in anticipation of special events like ballgames.