BART Needs $2bn in Capital Improvements
With this weekend’s Substation Melt-Down at BART’s Hayward Yard Storage
Facility, the opening shot has been fired in next year’s Labor Negotiations and, more importantly, establishes the need for future fare increases.
BART Spokesperson, Linton Johnson, appeared on ABC 7 News at 11 PM, Saturday night, and offered this analysis of the situation:
“BART is definitely 35 years old.”
“This is equipment that is aging but is so essential to running the trains because it provides the power and we’re two billion dollars in need.”
“We need two billion dollars in capital money to replace these facilities otherwise they age and they blow up like that.” (clip03)
Re-watch any of this weekend’s news coverage of the fire and you’ll see melted Busbars and other severe damage to substation equipment. Simple fires do not melt Busbars which are designed to handle thousands of amperes of current.
The extent of the damage done to the equipment is indicative of a seriously high current overload.
Persons at the scene said that after the first fire was extinguished, backup equipment was energized causing a second electrical explosion and subsequent fires.
The multiple explosions and fires at Hayward Yard were not caused by BART simply getting older, as Johnson states, but were almost certainly caused by human error.
Johnson also used his airtime to say that BART needs to come up with $2bn in the next five to ten years to replace all the old cars because they’re “not worth maintaining.”
The London Underground, started in 1863, somehow manages to operate a system with 268 stations and over 253 miles of track using a mix of cars that are nearly 50 years old! How DO they do it?
With BART ridership expected to increase by 140,000 passengers in the next few years, Johnson says, “We need to have three doors on each side, versus the two doors we have on each side now, otherwise we’re just going to paralyze ourselves.” (clip06)
BART’s spin machine is definitely gearing-up to scare the public into
believing BART’s entire infrastructure is on the verge of collapse.
Too bad tens of millions of dollars were wasted on the failed “Advanced
Automatic Train Control” (AATC) system. That money could have been used for real improvements like carpets instead of rubber flooring or seat cleaning.
--TOD

And word is that "human
And word is that "human error" was caused by a pretty high-up.....
Information is starting to
Information is starting to trickle down as to the real cause of the incident. Let’s just hope, if it proves true that the order came from high above, that person frys just like the substation did.
Too often at BART, bad decisions and damage are covered up and the persons responsible for them are protected because they know someone big in power -- the derailment outside Fremont Station 10-15 years ago comes to mind.
The Train Controller that did that was in training and on probation, yet kept his job . . . go figure.
This expensive incident was most definitely NOT caused by old equipment.
--TOD
I like his comment about
I like his comment about needing three doors.
The only way to do that is to loose more seats which will require running more cars.
AC-Transit tried three door buses, it did not help.
NY Transit has forty year
NY Transit has forty year old cars running off the miles.
As to $$ allocations, carpets were a dumb idea from the get go.
Of course Linton will spin internal mistakes to be a need for more money.
As to labor, California needs the "Taylor Law" because public transit is not a luxury.
35 years old my ass! I am 38
35 years old my ass! I am 38 and feel like I am better shape than BART. It simply boils down to how well you take care of what you have. If you take care of yourself and live well, than it shows. If you run yourself into the ground, drink, smoke and live bad, it also shows.
Re-watch any of this
Re-watch any of this weekend’s news coverage of the fire and you’ll see melted Busbars and other severe damage to substation equipment.
Uh, yeah...that's going to be pretty hard to explain as "fire damage." I'm dying to hear the details on this -- all you insiders need to start leaking to the media ASAP. :-)
Does anyone have links to photos? I'm particularly interested in the details mentioned above.